Wednesday, January 28, 2015

American Jellies: Josie Maran Coconut Watercolor Cheek Gelées

Last year, I tried for the first time and fell in love with jelly finish in cream cheek products. While it's more of an Asian beauty trend and not widely available among Western brands, there is a jelly product you can get easily if you live in the US: the Josie Maran Coconut Watercolor Cheek Gelées ($22 for 0.18 oz). I seem to have acquired two shades in very quick succession: Pink Escape, via Sephora's Beauty Insider perk (hence the dinky pot), and Getaway Red, because... strawberry jelly! I wish it smelt like berry gelée too, but, alas - absolutely no scent on these.
Here's the Sephora blurb for you, lifted from the website: 'This buildable, blendable blush hybrid provides the natural look of a cream blush with the long-lasting hydrating color of a gel stain. Infused with 50 percent pure coconut water, it instantly hydrates while nourishing with the powerful benefits of vitamin E-rich argan oil. Like a refreshing sip of coconut water for your skin, this moisture-packed blush instantly drenches cheeks in a cool veil of color'. End of blurb. There are eight colors in the line, ranging from sunny orange to deep wine.
A quick look at the ingredients proves that the Watercolor Gelées indeed contain quite a bit of coconut water (yum!), as well as moisturizing glycerin and argan oil. Josie Maran's product line could be described as 'aiming to be natural', and while there IS some lab-produced chemistry in there (shock horror! Nah, I don't care...), it's nice to know this blush is vegan, paraben, gluten and cruelty-free.
Can we contemplate the merry squishiness of the untouched product for a moment? Aaaah... Purdy. Now, when you touch your finger to the blush inside, it does indeed have a somewhat stiff gelatinous texture to it - interesting! Through a lot of trial and error, I've found that applying with a small duo fiber stippling brush dabbed straight into the jar works the best for me, because these are jelly STAINS, and they set incredibly quickly. I do a couple of very fast and vigorous blending motions with my brush to avoid concentrated patches of color. Trying to pick up color with your fingers results in most of the product staining your fingers, not your cheeks.
Those difficulties aside, I find these Watercolor Cheek Gelées to be a very cool (literally) and unique concept. They do feel nice and cooling on your skin, so they'd be perfect for hot summer months - also, they really are long-wearing. The pigmentation is on the sheer side (so they're not as scary as they look in the pot... Or who am I kidding, when am I ever scared by a bright blush?) but buildable, and the fun, punchy colors stand out on the skin and give it a natural, radiant flush. These Gelées also feel and look beautifully lightweight on the cheeks, there's literally no product feel to these, so if you like invisible blush that provides that glowing from within look, you need to give them a good swatch session.
Please don't be turned off by my swatches - I will admit that these are pants in arm swatches, they just don't lend themselves to being laid on thick; so if you want more opacity on your cheeks, I'd recommend thin layers rather than smacking half the jar on at once. For science, I did try these on the lips as well, and they're quite subtle and pretty when dabbed on; they don't even feel dry or tight, and that's a big achievement for a stain. I especially like to wear the Gelées under a sheer lipgloss to amp up the brightness a bit.
Compared to my favorite jellies of 2014, the Canmake Cream Cheeks in the clear finish, the Josie Maran Cheek Gelées are thinner in consistency and more sheer, and they almost have a bit of that dry silicone feel, although definitely less than the Revlon PhotoReady Cream Blush. The difference in textures of these three cheek products boils down to this, in my opinion: Canmake Cream Cheek is a cream jelly, Josie Maran is a gel jelly (wtf?), Revlon Photoready Cream Blush is a translucent cream to powder. As for the shades, Pink Escape is a cool toned/ just in from the cold pink (very similar to Revlon Flushed), while Getaway Red is a cool toned/ pinky red.
L-R: Josie Maran Pink Escape, Canmake Cream Cheek in CL04 Clear Pink Joy, Revlon PhotoReady Cream Blush in Flushed, Josie Maran Getaway Red, Canmake Cream Cheek in CL03 Clear Orange
Wearing Getaway Red on them apples. Also, wonky eyebrow -_-
All things considered, I'm having a lot of fun with these Watercolor Cheek Gelées; it's one of the more interesting formulations I've played around with in the recent months. I will say that they're not the easiest product to apply evenly, and they can cling to textural imperfections on the cheeks, but I feel that the same can be said about a lot of other stains - and the Gelées are way cooler than your average stain. So, yeah - go prod them at your local Sephora. What is your favorite cheek stain? Or do you skip creams and jellies altogether and simply prefer powder blushes?

22 comments:

  1. Hey Monika, oh these look so squishy indeed! I don't really go out of my way to try any type of stain products, but I did recently give the new Dior Cheek & Lip Glow a go and it's a hit (on the cheeks. I just have much better stuff for the lips)! I like how natural Getaway Red looks on you, and your lashes. Ahhh

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Sunny, I know what you mean about stains - I didn't really expect these to be as staining to be honest, but I think that unlike some of the liquid stains, the texture of Josie Maran Gelees is easier to work with. I remember Lily's review of the Dior's stain - she said it was super runny, I think? I'll have to swatch it next time I'm at the counter. Thank you! xoxo

      Delete
  2. The wibbly squish of the josie marans look so YUMMY! Is it weird that the first reaction I have looking at the pristine jars is thinking about eating them?

    And then I thought how lovely and fresh it looks applied on your cheek! <3

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh Belly, I don't think your reaction is weird at all - I was imagining Getaway Red spread on a sandwich, so... Yeah. Thank you! <3

      Delete
  3. I was really happy with the one I bought last summer. It was perfect for a wedding I was in. Also, your lashes look amazing! What mascara did you use for this picture?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad to hear you've had good experience with yours! Thank you Aimee, it's the Tarte Lights, Camera, Flashes I just reviewed in my previous post :)

      Delete
  4. I have two of these and love them too! I think they look really natural and last forever. They're great for traveling and the summer I agree! This one looks pretty on you!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I've really wanted to try them but the sheer aspect of them kind of puts me off - I prefer powder blushes truth be told, and even cream to powders tend to suit me better than stains like this. I think if I didn't have the acne scarring on my cheeks I would adore something like this - I still want to try it out though!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know what you mean, Emma - these can catch on imperfections a bit like all stains are wont to do, I have that issue too. I do go back and conceal the bigger hyperpigmentation marks after I'm done applying, but it's always a bit of a hassle. Getting acne on your cheeks is just so not fun :/

      Delete
  6. Topshop has exactly the same products on Feelunique, for those living in Europe. I'm really happy with my berry tone from Josie, it's just enough sheer.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I didn't know that, thank you for sharing Sara! Haha, these look a bit eye-searing in the pot but they sheer out beautifully on the cheeks :)

      Delete
  7. Mmm... they look GOOD! I have been eyeing them for a while, have tried them on a cpl. of times, and quite enjoyed how they looked on me! So subtle. I may go for one of these once I finish my current blush (which will be a while, even though it's a mini that I got as a gift).

    For some odd reason, these also make me hungry, thanks to words like coconut water and jelly ;).

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ohh.. you know how much I love JM gelée! Everything about it is good.. but I think mine has started to pull from the packaging a bit (aka drying out). Ack! Plenty of jelly goodness still, though, and the best part is this is wearable all season. Love the jelly on you, too!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Claire, I think yours was the first blog I saw Getaway Red on, and I knew I had to have it! Eh, cream blushes always have a shorter lifespan unfortunately :( Thank you! <3

      Delete
  9. I think I want one! I love that there is a mini version, too. I like stains on cheeks - that sheer, translucent flush is hard to beat!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I'm sold! Gimme Josie Maran jelly stains now! Haha. Seriously, I have never read a more convincing review on this product! :D It looks quite natural, too!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hahah, Jaa, even through my crappy swatches? :) Thank you!

      Delete
  11. I just bought one of these recently and LOVE it! The others are definitely going on my wish list.

    ReplyDelete
  12. pretties! but i'm too lazy to figure out which brush in my collection will work with these. this also reminds me that i have a canmake blush which i never give love to :(

    ReplyDelete
  13. Lovely review, Monika! I've always wanted to buy these (gel + jelly!! Two of my favourite things!), but I don't wear a lot of colour on my cheeks -- the immoveable stain that these deliver is too much for me.

    That texture, though. /heart eyes

    ReplyDelete
  14. I just bought this online and couldn't figure out how to get the stain to go on my cheeks and not my fingers. I will try your tip of using a duo brush; thanks! Also, what mascara are you wearing? Your lashes look great! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Jenn! I'm glad I could be of use :) I'm sorry, but I don't remember 100% which mascara I was wearing at that time, although judging from my posts, it was probably Tarte's Lights, Camera, Flashes; you can read my review by clicking on the post title in my archive on the right ------->

      Delete